490,000+ drivers found their agreements with us
For most civil and consumer disputes in the UK, mediation and other forms of ADR settle matters faster, more cheaply and in private, while court remains the route when you need urgent orders, compelled evidence or a legally binding, appealable judgment. Courts themselves now actively refer or stay many County Court claims for mediation under HMCTS pilot rules, so the two routes increasingly work together rather than as strict alternatives.
TL;DR:
- Government research found 44% of consumer ADR cases concluded within three months, while 81% of consumers reported direct costs below £50.
- Mediation is confidential, but its settlement becomes enforceable only through a written agreement or court consent order; arbitration awards are binding.
- Choose court when you need an urgent injunction, compelled documents or witness evidence, or an appealable judgment, because ADR cannot provide those powers.
- Eligible County Court small claims issued from May 22, 2024, through April 6, 2027, can be referred to mediation, pausing proceedings for 28 days.
- Keep a written record if the other party refuses a reasonable mediation offer, because the court may consider that refusal when awarding costs.
Alternative dispute resolution is not one process but several, and mediation is just the best known of them. GOV.UK’s mediation guidance makes this distinction clear: ADR is the umbrella term, and mediation, negotiation, conciliation, arbitration and adjudication all sit underneath it, each with different rules on who decides the outcome and whether that outcome binds you.
Understanding which one you are being offered matters, because a proposal from the other side, a solicitor or the court itself might use these terms loosely.
Consumer and smaller commercial disputes tend to suit mediation or conciliation, construction leans on adjudication, and contracts with an arbitration clause will usually require you to use it before any court action.
The practical differences between routes are where most people make their decision, and the data backs up the general reputation ADR has for being the lighter-touch option.
81% of ADR users reported costs under £50, a figure that illustrates why consumer bodies push ADR first for lower-value disputes.
Court fees sit on a published scale, set out in the EX50A civil court fees table, which varies by claim value and the type of application made, so it is worth checking the current table rather than assuming a flat figure. Worth noting too: a failed attempt at ADR does not disappear once you issue a claim, it adds time and cost on top of whatever the court process then requires.
ADR cannot deliver everything, and leaning on it when court powers are genuinely needed can cost you the remedy you are after.
If you do proceed to court, expect a claim to be issued, a defence filed, directions for evidence and disclosure, and then either a hearing or, increasingly, a referral back to mediation before trial.
Courts no longer treat ADR as something separate from litigation, they build it into case management. Under Practice Direction 51ZE, eligible small claims issued in the County Court between 22 May 2024 and 6 April 2027 can be automatically referred to the Small Claims Mediation Service, with proceedings stayed for 28 days to allow mediation to happen.
For many claimants, this means the question is no longer “ADR or court” but “which stage of the court process will involve ADR”.
Work through a short checklist before deciding how to proceed, rather than defaulting to whichever route feels more familiar.
Pro Tip: If the other side refuses a reasonable offer to mediate, keep a written record of the refusal, since courts can take unreasonable refusal into account when awarding costs.
Where the other party simply will not engage, your remaining options are to notify the court of the refusal, use that record to support a costs argument later, or proceed straight to issuing a claim.
Car finance disputes sit in an unusual spot between consumer ADR and formal legal claims management. We work as a claims manager, running a free check that locates car finance agreements and checking eligibility before referring suitable cases to partner solicitors who handle the legal steps, whether that ends in a negotiated settlement or court action.
We do not provide legal representation ourselves, and we do not decide whether ADR or court suits your case: that judgement sits with the law firm handling your claim once it is referred.
— Jake
If you think you were mis-sold a car finance agreement, working out whether that dispute belongs in mediation, a financial ombudsman scheme or court is exactly the kind of decision a specialist solicitor should make, not something to guess at alone.
We built our free check to find your car finance agreements in under 60 seconds, with no vehicle registration or lender paperwork needed from you. Once we locate a potentially mis-sold agreement, we refer eligible cases to a partner law firm, who will advise directly on the right route, including whether ADR, an ombudsman scheme or court action fits your circumstances.
For disputes outside car finance, such as unpaid invoices between sole traders, tools like TradeTally’s invoice dispute playbook set out a similar staged approach to resolving matters quickly before they escalate.
Run our free car finance check to see whether you have a claim worth pursuing.
This article is general information, not a substitute for advice from a qualified lawyer. Consult a qualified legal professional about your own circumstances before acting on anything here.
No, mediation is one specific form of ADR, not a synonym for it. GOV.UK’s guidance lists mediation alongside negotiation, conciliation, arbitration and adjudication as separate methods that fall under the broader ADR umbrella.
Conciliation is a form of ADR where an independent third party actively helps the parties reach an agreement, often going further than a mediator by proposing possible terms for settlement. It remains non-binding unless both sides accept the proposed terms and record them in a formal agreement.
Tribunals are specialist judicial bodies that hear specific types of case, such as employment or immigration appeals, through a first-tier and an Upper Tribunal structure, as set out in HMCTS tribunal statistics guidance. Courts handle the wider range of civil, family and criminal matters, and the two are distinct judicial routes rather than ADR options.
The usual arrangement is that both parties share the mediator’s fee equally, though this varies by scheme, according to GOV.UK’s mediation guidance. Some routes, including the Small Claims Mediation Service referred to under Practice Direction 51ZE, are offered free of charge for eligible County Court claims.