490,000+ drivers found their agreements with us
If your car was stolen while it was on PCP, you have two separate things to sort out: the theft itself (police, insurer, lender) and, entirely apart from that, whether the finance agreement was mis-sold. The theft does not cancel the second question. A car finance claim is about how the agreement was sold to you, not about what happened to the car afterwards, so a stolen or written-off car does not automatically rule you out. Below we cover the order of events after a theft, why you can still owe money, and how a claim fits in.
Get the order right, because insurers and lenders will ask for the same reference numbers.
The police pass the theft on to the DVLA, but the lender will still expect to hear from you directly.
Yes, in most cases. This catches many people out. The finance agreement is a separate contract from your insurance policy. Until the lender has been paid in full, the debt carries on, and missed payments can lead to arrears, default notices and damage to your credit file.
If money is tight, speak to your lender early about the situation rather than stopping payments. If you are struggling with debt more broadly, a free adviser such as Citizens Advice or StepChange can help you plan.
On PCP and hire purchase, the finance company owns the car until the final payment. That has a direct effect on who is paid. As cinch explains, the insurer pays the legal owner first, which is the lender.
The insurer values the car at its market value on the day it was stolen. It does not pay the price you originally paid, and it does not pay your remaining balance. If the payout is larger than what you owe, the surplus comes to you. If it is smaller, you are left with the gap.
These figures are illustrative only, not from any real case.
| Example A | Example B | |
|---|---|---|
| Insurer’s market value | £10,500 | £10,500 |
| Outstanding finance | £9,200 | £12,000 |
| Paid to lender | £10,500 | £10,500 |
| Result for you | £1,300 back | £1,500 still owed |
Example B is the common problem in the early years. The ABI explains that a vehicle starts losing value the moment you buy it, so the balance on a young agreement can sit above what the car is worth. Guaranteed Asset Protection (GAP) insurance is designed to cover that difference. If you did not buy it, ask your lender how the shortfall will be handled and whether a payment plan is available.
A PCP also has a large optional final payment at the end. If you were paying toward that balloon figure, your outstanding balance may be higher than you expect, so ask the lender for a settlement figure in writing.
This is the question behind the search, so it deserves a straight answer.
Mis-sold car finance claims are about what happened when the agreement was arranged. The issues the FCA has focused on include commission arrangements between the lender and the dealer or broker that were not properly disclosed to the customer. None of that depends on whether you still have the car. In our experience of how these claims work, the agreement itself is what matters: who the lender was, when it started, and how it was set up.
Two caveats:
It is also worth remembering that a theft often means a new finance agreement soon afterwards, to replace the car. You may therefore have more than one agreement that could be looked at, the old one and the new one.
The FCA confirmed that it is going ahead with a compensation scheme for motor finance customers treated unfairly. Key points from its statement:
The practical upshot: the process is moving, but not as fast as many people hoped. Be wary of quick lender offers made during this period. An early figure may be lower than what a full calculation would give, so ask how it was worked out before you accept anything.
If you have already lost the car to theft, you may feel you have enough to deal with. That is fair, and nothing here needs to be done in the same week as the insurance claim. Do the theft steps first, and look at the finance question when you are ready.
We are a claims management company, and we see the same assumption often: “I no longer have the car, so I cannot have a claim.” We understand why people think that, but the question is about the original sale of the finance, not the vehicle. The difficulty for most people is more practical. They no longer have the paperwork, they cannot remember which lender it was, and the registration number is of no use to them now.
That is exactly why we built our check the way we did. It does not ask for your registration or any lender documents. It looks for your agreements for free, in under 60 seconds, so a stolen car, a lost folder or a house move does not stand in your way. If an agreement shows up, it can be passed to an affiliated law firm, which handles the claim for you. That firm has a record of successful UK Supreme Court cases and above-average claim awards. You do not chase the lender or fill in a stack of forms.
One honest note: there is a free route too. The FCA scheme does not require you to use a claims company or a law firm. If you would rather deal with your lender directly, you can. Our service is for people who want the legwork done for them. Whichever route you pick, do not sign anything you do not understand, and check what any firm charges before you agree.
— Jake
If your PCP or HP car was stolen, or written off, or sold years ago, you can still run our free check. It finds your car finance agreements without your registration number or any lender paperwork, and it covers agreements back to 2007. It costs nothing to see what turns up. If you want to understand the whole process first, our guide on how to claim car finance compensation in the UK walks through it.
You report it to the police and get a crime reference number, then tell your insurer and your finance company. The insurer pays the market value to the lender, as the legal owner. You keep paying the finance until the account is settled, and you are responsible for any shortfall unless you have GAP insurance.
Often yes, because the claim concerns how the agreement was sold, not whether you still have the car. Whether you qualify depends on the details of the agreement, such as the commission arrangement. A free check can show which agreements you had.
It works much like theft. The insurer pays the car’s market value, the lender is paid first, and you may be left with a shortfall if the balance is higher. Financial.org.uk sets out how this applies across the main agreement types.
Our check is free. Under the FCA scheme you also do not need to use a claims company or law firm to take part. If you do use one, make sure you understand any fee before agreeing.